On February 14, 2016, the Hartford Preservation Alliance announced its Ten Most Endangered Buildings List with its HARTBomb Event. These properties are:
1. 16 HARVARD STREET
Neighborhood: Southwest
Style: Greek Revival
Year Built: circa 1850
This single-family home is one only 44 known Hartford buildings built before 1860 that are still standing. It is currently listed on the city’s vacant property list. It is not located within one of our 53 local, state or national historic districts and therefore is not protected from demolition under the city’s Historic Preservation Ordinance.
2. 23-25 MADISON STREET
Neighborhood: Frog Hollow
Historic District: Frog Hollow National Historic District
Style: Italianate
Year Built: circa 1870
Problems with the neglect of this building goes back to the 1990’s. Much of the original architectural details remain including brownstone window surrounds, period doors and porch details. Returning the structure to a double house is recommended.
3. 2285 MAIN STREET
Neighborhood: Northeast
Historic District: Capen-Clark National Historic District
Style: Italianate
Year Built: circa 1860-1870
The out-of-state owner’s recent request to demolish this classic Italianate structure has been denied by Hartford’s Historic Preservation Commission but demolition by neglect remains a real possibility. Once filled with majestic architecture, Main Street north of downtown has been ignored for too long, resulting in an overabundance of vacant buildings and lots that put a strain on city services and do nothing to stimulate neighborhood growth and economic development.
4. 3372 MAIN STREET
Neighborhood: Northeast
Style: Queen Anne
Year Built: circa 1890
This enchanting Queen Anne residence was built (along with its “sister” at 3364) by the sons of Timothy Mather a prosperous dairy farmer who owned approximately 1,000 acres in the area. The survival of many of its original architectural details, including windows, porch trim and exterior shingles, make this a rare find outside of the West End neighborhood. Although certainly qualified, this building is not currently listed on the State Historic Register and lacks protection under the city’s Historic Preservation Ordinance – little could be done to prevent demolition or the loss of its character should the owner decide to vinyl side over the exterior and/or replace the windows.
5. 250 SISSON AVENUE
Neighborhood: West End
Historic District:
Sisson-South Whitney
National Historic District
Style: Queen Anne
Year Built: circa 1890
Vinyl siding and replacement windows have erased much of the architectural character of this home. Most concerning is the deterioration of the original carriage barn in the rear. With so few of them remaining it seems short sighted to allow its loss by neglect. Small outbuildings such as these make create artist studios and small retail stores.
6. 903 ASYLUM AVENUE
Neighborhood: Asylum Hill
Historic District: Asylum Hill National Historic District
Name: The Capewell House
Style: Italianate
Year Built: 1870
This wonderfully intact Italianate double-house illustrates that beauty and majesty that was once “The Hill” before the development of commercial and apartment buildings. This property was nominated to our list by the Asylum Hill Revitalization Zone. A below average level of maintenance and possible financial difficulties are cause for concern. This was once the home of George Capewell, whose factory building in the Sheldon-Charter Oak neighborhood is being rehabilitated into residential units by CIL. Would that someone would take on this building as well and restore her to former glory.
7. 479 FARMINGTON AVENUE
Neighborhood: West End
Historic District:
Sisson-South Whitney
National Historic District
Name: Colonial Arms
Style: Classic Revival
Year Built: 1921
Architect: Berenson & Moses
This early 20th century mixed-use commercial building was the lead subject in a 2011 Hartford Courant special report about code violations in city buildings (see Fires, Blight: Vicious Cycle, May 1, 2011 by Josh Kovner). The owner’s refusal to make necessary repairs has resulted in this building remaining vacant (with the exception of one commercial tenant). It is yet another example of the vacant buildings that are beginning to multiply on Farmington Avenue, the most travelled street in the city and the gateway through which workers and visitors travel downtown from the western suburbs. These mixed-used buildings are often the cornerstones for walkable neighborhoods but they need to be occupied and maintained.
8. 220 HIGH STREET
Neighborhood: Downtown
Historic District:
Downtown North
National Historic District
Style: Italianate
Year Built: circa 1865
This Civil War-era building was built by merchant tailor Franklin E. Pettibone and escaped demolition last year after concerned citizens voiced their opposition to razing the structure for a later phase of the Downtown North redevelopment project. Given the proliferation of vacant lots in our downtown area, no buildings should be demolished – whether on a historic register or not – until plans are approved and financing is in place for its replacement. The Alliance has offered to the city an alternative plan for the site whereby the Pettibone house is reused and sets the tone for a design that celebrates the architectural history of the neighborhood.
HPA vision for 220 High Street (rendering: Valerio Giadone)
9. JEFFERSON STREET 
(between Main & Washington)
Neighborhood: South Green
Historic District:
Jefferson-Seymour
National Historic District (partial)
Year Built: 1865–1934
Last year saw the loss of three buildings in this area – two Italianates and the D. Newton Barney Building. The majority of the property on the north side of the street between Washington Street and Seymour Street stand vacant, including the architecturally and historically significant Levi Felt House. Preservationists are mindful that new construction is necessary to meet this century’s technological demands. We also know there are ways to achieve this AND preserve the architecture that defines the neighborhood.
10. 267 FARMINGTON AVENUE
Neighborhood: Asylum Hill
Historic District:
Asylum Hill
National Historic District
Name: Comet Diner
Style: Diner
Year Built: 1948
Although by far the most recognized and popular building on our 2015 Endangered Properties list, the Comet is still threatened. While the newly adopted Form Based Zoning Code guides any new construction and/or infill for this site, our municipal preservation protections would not preclude the moving of the diner to another site, including out of state. A visionary developer who sees the diner as a jewel and not a roadblock is needed to help jump start the redevelopment of this area of the Farmington Avenue Corridor.
For further information on these or any other historic Hartford building,
feel free to contact:
Mary A. Falvey, Assistant Director
Hartford Preservation Alliance
office: 860.570.0331 ext. 2
email: mary@hartfordpreservation.org